Who Killed Tara Collins On Innocent? The Suspects Revealed From Alice And Rob Moffatt To David Collins And His Brother Phil


INNOCENT viewers have been gripped trying to work out who really killed Tara Collins.

After David Collins is released from jail after seven years, the fingers turn on other people who were close to Tara. But who is guilty and who is innocent? We take a look at the main suspects.

David Collins

� Steffan Hill 2016 David Collins, played by Lee Ingleby, has been released but is he guilty

David, played by Lee Ingleby, was jailed for seven years for his wife’s murder but in the first episode he is released on a technicality.

But despite always protesting his innocence and being freed, many still believe he killed Tara.

In the initial trial, which was led by DI William Beech, he was initially put away because his blood was found on Tara’s coat.

He also had no alibi because his best mate Tom changed the time he said he left his house – and a witness said they heard a woman’s scream coming from his house.

His relationship with Tara was thought to be troubled – and according to his sister, he used to beat her.

However the case falls apart somewhat when DI Cathy Hudson starts investigating and discovers the scream coming from the house could have actually been a fox.

She learns that Tara’s fractured cheek was actually the result of a fight with her lover Tom – and not from a fight with David.

Tom finally admits he lied about when he left their house that night – meaning David does have an alibi.

Alice Moffatt

� Steffan Hill 2016 It seems Alice Moffatt hasn’t been telling the whole truth

Alice Moffatt, played by Hermione Norris, has quickly become a key suspect after a series of her lies started to unravel.

Firstly it turns out her relationship with her sister was far from rosy – they had in fact had a nasty row on the night she died, which has been proved by a witness who saw her push her against a wall and also a series of aggressive text messages.

Secondly, she has always wanted children of her own but was unable to have them

She gave different accounts to the police about why she couldn’t conceive and it emerged that she had borrowed thousands from Tara for IVF. Tara later refused to give her any more money.

Following Tara’s death, Alice started looking after her children, insisting they call her mum. She also took over her wealthier sister’s estate.

Finally, her car was caught speeding near where Tara was on the night of her death.

Rob Moffatt

� Steffan Hill 2016 Is Rob Moffatt as unassuming as he seems?

Rob Moffatt, played by Adrian Rawlins, initially appeared rather unassuming but  by the third episode he was leaving viewers feeling a little uneasy.

Like his wife, he really wanted children and plays the doting dad to Tara’s kids, which was of course only able to happen once she died.

He is very good with knots, which were used to tie up Tara’s body and he made no secret of disliking his wife’s sister.

Perhaps most importantly, he admitted that he was driving the car which was caught speeding near where Tara was on the night she died.

He claimed he was picking up anti-depressants for his wife at a late night pharmacy, but didn’t disclose this information until seven years later.

Phil Collins

� Steffan Hill 2016 Phil campaigned for his brother’s release but is he hiding something?

Phil Collins, played by Daniel Ryan, campaigned for seven years for his brother’s release.

He seems to be struggling with living with his brother again and is very keen for him to put his past behind him.

Interestingly, he’s also very sure that Alice, Tom and Rob are not guilty of the crime – leading viewers to wander what he knows that we don’t.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *